Last November just before Thanksgiving, I shared Grandma Honeywell's pumpkin pie recipe here on Horsiemama. It is my favorite pie, but the rest of my family thinks her cherry pie is even better. I will be making both this week and thought that I would share her cherry pie recipe this year.
This recipe does not use store-bought cherry pie filling, it uses pitted tart red cherries.
My original recipe card from the mid 1970s. You can tell that it is well loved and well used! I have also added notes to it - they continue on to the back. (I double the filling now despite what my 1997 note says. And, I omit the salt.)
Grandma Honeywell's 1955 Cherry Pie Recipe
2 cans of cherries, drained in a colander with the juice saved
1 cup sugar
2 1/2 tablespoons quick cooking tapioca (NOT the pearled!)
1/3 cup of the saved juice (discard the rest)
1 tablespoon butter, thinly sliced into pats (sometimes I omit this, too)
Preheat oven to 450 degrees. Combine the sugar, tapioca, and cherry juice in a medium bowl. Stir until well mixed and let stand while preparing the pie dough. Roll out half the pie dough (or use a prepared crust) and place bottom crust into a 9" pie pan. Mix the cherries into the sugar/tapioca/juice mixture and then pour into the pie pan. Place thin butter pats on top of cherry mixture. Roll out the other half of the pie dough (or use prepared pie crust) and place on top. Cut a few steam vents into the top. Bake at 450 degrees for ten minutes, then turn the heat down to 350 degrees and bake for 30 minutes.
Now, because there are 29 Isenbargers and every last one of us loves homemade pie, I always double the recipe. It's easy peasy - I use 5 cans of cherries and 10" pie pans. (Just roll the dough thinner to fit the pie pan.) I do not change anything else in Grandma Honeywell's recipe.
When doubling, I make each recipe twice in separate bowls.
The cherries and sugar/tapioca/juice have been mixed together and poured into the pie pan.
Dotting the top with butter before adding the top crust.
The top crust has been added, the edges fluted, and the steam vent cut into the top crust. (Use the tip of a sharp knife to cut your vents. Hold it vertically to the pie crust and cut with a quick, shallow, up and down motion.)Hot out of the oven and cooling on the counter.
Cowpoke Ian checking out the desserts - the cherry pie is the bottom right pie.
Because our family is so big and there is so much food being prepared, we run out of space quickly. The solution to the space crunch? Putting completed dishes that do not need refrigeration in other places in the house - on top of the the washing machine, outside on the patio table (which sometimes doubles as a second refrigerator if the weather is cold enough), and...
... in the tub in my bathroom. As you can see, Cowpoke Ian has discovered them. Usually all the grands have to come take a peek. They get the giggles when they see pies in the bathtub.Grandma started baking this cherry pie recipe in 1955, maybe earlier. It wouldn't be the holidays to me or to my family without a slice of it.I feel very close to her when I make it and often get a little teary, too. She passed the recipe to my mom who passed it to me, and I have passed it on to my children. An unusual legacy, but a very important one, too.
Enjoy your cherry pie, and Happy Thanksgiving!