Last year for the first time ever, I took a stab at guessing who the BreyerFest Mystery Surprise Horse would be. It took a lot of thought and was harder than anticipated, so much so that the very next day, I revised that guess! (And the model turned out to be Emerson who wasn't even on my list.)
This year's BreyerFest is celebrating Breyer's 75th anniversary and that helped shape my guess. To me, it is logical that they will be using an iconic mold, and most likely one that is well loved by collectors. I also suspect that the mold that is used will be a vintage one, reflecting that long history the company has.
First off, I eliminated the Western Horse - it's already being used in the 2025 regular run line.
Beloveds
Proud Arabian Mare
Lady Phase
Othello
Huckleberry Bey
Goffert
Semi Rearing Mustang
Fighting Stallion
Adios
Indian Pony
Silver
Stretch Morgan
Who might I have forgotten? I walked around and took a look at my own shelves, paying particularly close attention to the vintage molds. Silver and the Stretch Morgan were added to the Beloved list, but not these:
Vintage but Unlikely to be Used
Belgian
Balking Mule (I may change my mind on this mold)
Running Stallion
Running Mare
Clydesdale Stallion
Clydesdale Mare
Western Horse with Rider
Western Pony
Western Prancer with Rider
Almost all of these molds have a fan base, but I didn't feel they were iconic enough to be used for the company's 75th anniversary.
It's always possible that Breyer might really go big and do something they have never done before. Creating this next list of possibilities was a fun part of my guessing. I don't think they will happen, though.
Dreaming Big but No
Mare & Foal set
Stallion, Mare & Foal set
Foal set
Clocks, Lamps, Music Boxes
Flockies (maybe as the decorator?)
A variety of vintage molds in vintage colors, not just one single mold used for the Surprise Horse
Satisfied that I had a strong list of contenders for the Surprise model, I went back to the Beloved list and then checked them against the list of who had been a Dinner Model/Celebration Horse, which would have given them even more use/exposure at BreyerFest. (I did not check them against having been BreyerFest LEs and SRs. Just too many to look at and record.)
Used as a Dinner Model/Celebration Horse?
Proud Arabian Mare - never
Lady Phase - 2000, Leah's Fancy Chic
Othello - 2012, Mariah's Boon
Huckleberry Bey - 2001, Atlantis Bey
Goffert - 2014, Gooitzen fan Teakesyl
Semi Rearing Mustang - 1993, Turbo the Wonder Horse
Fighting Stallion - never
Adios - 1995, Mego
Indian Pony - 1992, Mustang Lady
Silver - never
Stretch Morgan - never
As you can see from the highlighting, four of my top guesses have never been Dinner Models/Celebration Horses:
Fighting Stallion - extremely popular and second Vintage Club offering
Proud Arabian Mare - extremely popular
Silver - extremely popular
Stretch Morgan - moderately popular, especially with long time hobbyists
It was while looking at that list that two of those iconic beloveds jumped out at me. "There are my strongest contenders," I thought to myself. Still, I spent some time looking at the "Final Four" before making my guess,
First, I eliminated the Stretch Morgan. When compared to the Proud Arabian Mare, Fighting Stallion, and Silver, he is not nearly as popular as them. This is a very big anniversary that Breyer is celebrating and I think they are going to go big with the Mystery Surprise Horse.
Then, I eliminated Silver. That was hard - while he is highly popular, I think the other two represent the 75th anniversary better. Having said that, Silver is my third choice as to who the model will be and it would not surprise me (no pun intended) if he does, in fact, end up being the mold Breyer uses.
My guess this year is:
1st choice - Proud Arabian MareShe's beautiful,
2nd choice - Fighting Stallion
- The PAM is more conformationally correct, a big plus for those who like to live show.
- She has never been done in the big four decorator colors (gold charm, wedgewood, florentine, and copenhagen) but the Fighting Stallion has and that would limit some of the options for the colors of the surprise horse if he were used. I think that it is highly possible that Breyer will bring back those four colors for the Mystery Surprise Horse.
(It also wouldn't surprise me if they used a mix of vintage and modern colors along with the decorator colors - charcoal, 5 gaiter sorrel, red roan, and more.)
One last thought, though. There are two models who have been used as the Dinner Model/Celebration Horse twice:
- Rejoice (1998, 2010)
- Smart Chic Olena (2006, 2013)
A precedent for repeating a mold has been set elsewhere. Would Breyer repeat a former Mystery Surprise Horse mold? I don't think they will, but never say never.
Stay 'tooned!!

























