Earlier this week, I wrote a blog entry about my unusual Proud Arabian Stallion and asked readers if they could tell me anything about him. Long time hobbyist and tack maker Susan Bensema Young stepped up to the plate and, with her permission, I share her thoughts.
---
Here is Gren (Grenendere), veteran of nearly 50 years in my herd [47]. The necklace is a childhood survival; didn’t all Arabs have such things? I, who read King of the Wind,… :) and who was also influenced by Breyer, come to think of it.
The noticable white spot on his off hind hip (point of butt) is from an unfortunate falling accident :( while the strange smeary streaks on his off hindquarter are “original factory finish.” He came that way. Who knows under what conditions these horses were made...
Your near-chalky reminds me very much of my own Dapple Grey PAS, Grenendere. (nicknamed Gren.) He came into my life “sometime before July 4, 1976” (according to his card) and has the same very detailed surface, dense spots, beautiful shading and poorly cleaned mold lines as yours. He’s got the drying-rack dirt marks on his soles. His finish is somewhat thick-feeling and he looks a lot like a chalky, although I’ve never considered him one. This is probably because I don’t like chalkies! I would be disappointed if he turned out to be one! So let’s say I’m looking at him with eyes that don’t want to see a chalky…. He’s turning pretty yellow these days, but it gives him a beautiful richness of color.
Just like yours, he has lovely pink ears. AND nose. They haven’t faded. They aren’t that strong to begin with, but they’re definitely there. He has nothing unusual under his tail; in fact, I’d never looked at a PAS from that angle. How odd.
At the same time I acquired him, back in the mid-to-late 70s, I acquired a Dapple Grey PAM. I named her Darlene. At the time she was all the rage, a great catch for a collector. In the fullness of time she left my hands. It would be 40+ years before I saw her again,… what are the odds?,… when Christina Pilz, a childhood friend from Boulder, asked me to sell her carpet herd. I took delivery of boxes of models (this was 2021) and lo and behold, one was a Dapple Grey PAM named Darlene. Chris said she’d gotten her from me, — which I'd forgotten all about.

But this Darlene was the most obvious, in-your-face Chalky I’d ever seen! She was thick, pale, flat and ugly, with few spots and rudimentary shading. I sell my OFs through dealer Margaret Loesch (GreyWoodsCat on eBay) and Margaret hadn’t known what chalkies were. Well I was able to show her! Three of Chris’s horses were challkies — + an Appaloosa Running Stallion & a Clyde Foal — and they all went, I believe, for premium prices. I’ve never liked chalkies and I was rather turned off by Darlene. And surprised. Was my memory really that bad? Apparently it was.
My knowledge of what causes chalkiness is completely self-taught and probably totally wrong. I’ve noticed, across decades of warm-water reshaping to straighten legs, that if you boil them too hot or too long, the paint ‘cooks' and turns chalky. (And never goes back.) Perhaps (here goes pure speculation!) they just got too hot somewhere in the factory. Perhaps these dapple grey Stallions only experienced borderline conditions — maybe only a few moments of too hot — maybe poorly cooled before painting. An amateur’s explanation,… Perhaps whatever materials produced the effect — a kind of paint? — were only used in small portion for them. Hobby mythology explains that the scarcity of oil in the 70s caused Breyer to use less-than-satisfactory paint. From the looks of these mares, they also used less-than-satisfactory painting skill!I have pictures but not time now to process them. Here’s one unprocessed: Darlene is on the left. The PAM on the right is also Christina’s, named (appropriately enough) ‘Christina.’ Didn’t they make some beautiful dapple greys back then,…! and almost certainly, this darker mare is older than Darlene. I have a face-on picture and neither one has pink at all.
I know this is a rabbit-hole. Thank you for reading.
---
Thanks for sharing, Sue - that's a fun habit hole to go down! In the next day or so, I will put the photos of Gren and my PAS together and take a closer look.
Stay 'tooned!